enter your email address and we'll send you your shopping cart:





Item Added to Cart
 
 
 

You have not viewed any products recently.

 
We carry 78 items like this in the warehouse.

Mystery

Sort By
View Grid List
 
 
Related Categories: Laffy Taffy Ropes | Candy Rope
Laffy Taffy Candy Ropes - Mystery Swirl: 24-Piece Box

Laffy Taffy Candy Ropes - Mystery Swirl: 24-Piece Box

Tangy, chewy ropes featuring a mysterious fruity swirl and a quirky joke on every wrapper! Rope Length: 10 Inches Display box contains 24 packs of Mystery Swirl Laffy Taffy Ropes Candy. Made in the USA. Shipping Weight ~ 2 lbs. Kosher Certified.

Add to Cart

$9.60

Dum Dums Pops: 1000-Piece Tub

Dum Dums Pops: 1000-Piece Tub

…plus the famous Mysterious one. You’ll love the experience. Flavors may include: Banana Split, Blue Raspberry, Bubblegum, Butterscotch, Cherry, Coconut, Cotton Candy, Cream Soda, Grape, Mango, Root Beer, Sour Apple, Strawberry, Strawberry Shortcake, Tangerine, Watermelon, and the Mystery Flavor. Tub…

Add to Cart

$75.00

Brach's Premium Mystery Flavors Christmas Candy Canes: 12-Piece Box

Brach's Premium Mystery Flavors Christmas Candy Canes:…

…Christmas! Brach's Mystery Flavors Candy Canes are gourmet versions of the original with unique colors and flavors that will surprise your taste buds with every lick! With this festive twist on the confectionery classics, these invigorating new Brach's Candy Canes offer mystery and suspense sure to…

Add to Cart

$3.60

Jelly Belly BeanBoozled Jelly Beans Mystery Bean Machine

Jelly Belly BeanBoozled Jelly Beans Mystery Bean…

…alike. Depending on your luck, you can taste lawn clippings or lime, stinky socks or tutti frutti, boogers or juicy pear from this purple cylinder Mystery Bean Machine. The list of weird flavors is never-ending. Watch your friends scrunch their faces in surprise or smile in sugary delight when they…

Add to Cart

$6.95

AirHeads Taffy Candy Bars - White Mystery: 36-Piece Box

AirHeads Taffy Candy Bars - White Mystery: 36-Piece Box

…ever-popular, ever mind-boggling White Mystery AirHeads that have everyone (including us) trying to guess their closest taste-alike. They’re creamy. They’re sweet. But even us candy experts can’t quite pin down their true flavor. See if you can solve the mystery yourself by unlocking the delicious…

Add to Cart

$9.00

Dum Dums Pops: 30LB Case

Dum Dums Pops: 30LB Case

…official flavors plus THE MYSTERY FLAVOR! Flavors may include: Banana Split, Blue Raspberry, Bubblegum, Butterscotch, Cherry, Coconut, Cotton Candy, Cream Soda, Grape, Mango, Root Beer, Sour Apple, Strawberry, Strawberry Shortcake, Tangerine, Watermelon, and the Mystery Flavor. Case 30 pounds of Dum…

Add to Cart

$147.00

AirHeads Taffy Candy Bars: 90-Piece Box

AirHeads Taffy Candy Bars: 90-Piece Box

…lotta crazy for you and your party guests. Now all you have to do is think of a reason to bust them out. That's the easy part. Includes an assortment of 6 fruity flavors: Cherry Watermelon White Mystery Blue Raspberry Orange Grape Each box contains 90 AirHeads Taffy Bars. Shipping Weight ~ 3 lbs.

Add to Cart

$22.50

Push Pop Candy: 24-Piece Box

Push Pop Candy: 24-Piece Box

…flavors - Strawberry Watermelon, Berry Blast, Raspberry Lemonade, Rainbow Sherbet, and new Blue Raspberry Watermelon. Plus, try new Black & White Mystery flavors for a delicious surprise treat! Dispenser Height: 3 Inches Display box contains 24 Push Pop Candy Dispensers. Shipping Weight ~ 3 lbs.…

Add to Cart

$24.00

Baby Bottle Pops: 18-Piece Box

Baby Bottle Pops: 18-Piece Box

…Sour Blue Raspberry, OR try Rainbow Sherbet, Berry Blast, Strawberry/Watermelon, and Tropical Punch - they're Twisted. For a fun surprise, try a Mystery Baby Bottle Pop with color changing powders. Can you guess what the flavor is? Unit Price = $2.00/bottle. Display box contains 18 Candy Powder…

Add to Cart

$36.00

AirHeads Bites Candy - Fruit: 9-Ounce Bag

AirHeads Bites Candy - Fruit: 9-Ounce Bag

…the go. We know, it will be hard not to eat them all in one sitting because they’re really delicious. Assorted Colors/Flavors: Green - Watermelon Blue - Raspberry Red - Cherry Orange - Orange White - Mystery Resealable bag contains 9 ounces of Fruit AirHeads Bites Candy. Shipping Weight ~ 3/4 lb.

Add to Cart

$3.95

Halloween Mega Candy Buttons Sheets: 2-Piece Pack

Halloween Mega Candy Buttons Sheets: 2-Piece Pack

…feature an fun assortment of spooky colors and flavors. Perfect for Halloween parties and events! Color - Flavor: Orange - Candy Corn White - Mystery Flavor Purple - Ghoulish Grape Green - Green Apple Button Diameter: 1/2 Inch Package includes 2 sheets of Halloween Mega Candy Buttons. Shipping…

Add to Cart

$2.95

Patriotic USA Tootsie Pops: 15-Piece Bag

Patriotic USA Tootsie Pops: 15-Piece Bag

…knows precisely how many licks it takes to get to the chewy center, not even our nation's large population of extremely wise owls. Celebrate the mystery and America with blue raspberry, vanilla and cherry Tootsie Pops wrapped up in red, white and blue. Bag contains 9 ounces of American Flag Red,…

Add to Cart

$3.95

SweeTarts Chews - Spree - Laffy Taffy - SweeTarts Candy Assortment: 185-Piece Bag

SweeTarts Chews - Spree - Laffy Taffy - SweeTarts Candy…

What is cool? It’s a mystery that’s baffled those of us over 30 for generations. Among candy, at least, there’s a clear answer -- Nestle, with its famous name, psychedelic design, and crazy candy concepts, has long been a favorite of kids and preteens alike. This bag contains SweeTarts Original,…

Add to Cart

$18.50

AirHeads Striped Taffy Mini Candy Bars Packs: 12-Piece Box

AirHeads Striped Taffy Mini Candy Bars Packs: 12-Piece…

…out of creating the perfect flavor combination. These tiny taffies come in stripes of Strawberry/Watermelon, Blue Raspberry/Cherry, and Double Mystery flavors. Eat the two sides separately, or munch on both at once. Display box contains 12 packs of AirHeads Striped Taffy Mini Candy Bars. Made in…

Add to Cart

$29.95

SweeTarts Mini Chewy Candy 3.75-Ounce Packs: 12-Piece Box

SweeTarts Mini Chewy Candy 3.75-Ounce Packs: 12-Piece…

…impossible to use in any such game, because the pieces seem to mysteriously vanish any time we turn our backs. Even more curiously, we often find our opponents chewing merrily while we search for the lost spheres! Their disappearance is a mystery we’ll never solve. But even though we don’t recommend…

Add to Cart

$24.00

Dum Dums Original Pops Ball Lollipops: 300-Piece Bag

Dum Dums Original Pops Ball Lollipops: 300-Piece Bag

…Cherry, Coconut, Cotton Candy, Cream Soda, Grape, Mango, Root Beer, Sour Apple, Strawberry, Strawberry Shortcake, Tangerine, Watermelon, and the Mystery Flavor. Bag contains 300 Dum Dum Pops. Made in the USA. Shipping Weight ~ 5 lbs. Kosher Certified. DISCLAIMER: Due to changes from time-to-time…

Add to Cart

$15.00

Palmer Peppermint Bark 4.5-Ounce Candy Bars: 18-Piece Box

Palmer Peppermint Bark 4.5-Ounce Candy Bars: 18-Piece…

…with peppermint pieces, to add a zesty little crunch to the otherwise creamy, melt-in-your-mouth confection. The only logical conclusion to the mystery of this chocolaty treat’s origin is that these trees did exist, hundreds of years ago, but they were devoured within minutes of discovery. And if…

Add to Cart

$29.70

Crime Scene Candy Tubes: 3-Piece Pack

Crime Scene Candy Tubes: 3-Piece Pack

Straight off the set of the CSI crime lab, these candy bodily fluids are everything you need to solve mysterious crimes and nab the candy crooks in your life. The crime scene candy assortment includes three biological liquid candies: Blood, Urine, and Saliva with corresponding flavors of Cherry,…

Add to Cart

$5.00

Valentine M&M's Candy Fun Size Packs: 30-Piece Bag

Valentine M&M's Candy Fun Size Packs: 30-Piece Bag

…red, white and pink M&Ms! Each packet of has a To/From label so your sweetie will know exactly who gave this tasty gift…or you could just remain a mysterious secret admirer! Bag contains 14 ounces of Valentine's Day M&M's Fun Size Candy Packets... that's about 30 packs. These M&Ms for Valentines…

Add to Cart

$10.50

Pop Rocks Candy Packs - Strawberry Watermelon Combo: 36-Piece Box

Pop Rocks Candy Packs - Strawberry Watermelon Combo: 36…

…on them behind his back. That fizzy, snapping, crackling sensation you feel after pouring a pack of Pop Rocks into your mouth has always been a mysterious thrill. Take this strawberry watermelon set for research. You’ll understand how the rockets, booms, and show-stopping lights burst with fruity…

Add to Cart

$36.00

Cadbury
Chupa Chups Lolllipops
Famous Amos
Haribo Gummy
Hershey's Kisses
jolly rancher candy
PEZ Candy
Sour Patch Candy
Starburst Candy
Swedish Fish Candy
Tootsie Roll Industries
Twizzlers Candy