enter your email address and we'll send you your shopping cart:

Item Added to Cart

You have not viewed any products recently.

We carry 78 items like that in the warehouse.

Mystery Candy

Sort By
View Grid List

Laffy Taffy Candy Ropes - Mystery Swirl: 24-Piece Box

Tangy, chewy ropes featuring a mysterious fruity swirl and a quirky joke on every wrapper! Rope Length: 10 Inches Unit Price = $0.40/piece. Display box contains 24 packs of Mystery Swirl Laffy Taffy Ropes Candy. Made in the USA. Shipping Weight ~ 2 lbs. Kosher Certified.



AirHeads Taffy Candy Bars - White Mystery: 36-Piece Box

…They’re sweet. But even us candy experts can’t quite pin down their true flavor. See if you can solve the mystery yourself by unlocking the delicious secrets hidden inside these chewy conundrums! Unit Price = $0.25/bar. Display box contains 36 White Mystery AirHeads Taffy Candy Bars, each with a net…



Pineapple Sassy Suckers White Striped Ball Lollipops - Petite: 400-Piece Bag

…the moon about these sizable Striped Ball suckers. Lined with white stripes, these tasty candies are long-lasting snacks with a beauty that’s all their own. Curved white lines stretch across the hard candy’s surface (just like Jupiter’s banded outer layer), and meet in the centers on the left and…



Jelly Belly BeanBoozled Jelly Beans Mystery Bean Machine

…the celebrated candy creators have pulled the ultimate card of chicanery by mixing good and bad beans that look exactly alike. Depending on your luck, you can taste lawn clippings or lime, stinky socks or tutti frutti, boogers or juicy pear from this purple cylinder Mystery Bean Machine. The…



AirHeads Mini Candy Bars: 80-Piece Bag

…to hear the candy strips humblebragging before dissolving into sugary morsels. "Yeah, I shrunk a few inches. So now all I wear are size 0 wrappers…in petite. Being skinny sucks." We know, AirHeads. We know. Flavor assortment includes: Blue Raspberry Cherry Grape Orange Watermelon White Mystery Candy



SweeTarts Chewy Sours Candy Rolls: 24-Piece Box

Shockingly tangy treats from the mysterious Willy Wonka candy factory, these SweeTarts Chewy Sours (previously known as SweeTarts Shockers) are sure to make your taste buds stand on end! Unit Price = $1.25/roll. Display box contains 24 rolls of SweeTarts Chewy Sours Candy. Made in the USA. Shipping…



Rock Candy Crystals - Red: 5LB Box

Rare ruby jewels mined from deep candy caves! Very mysterious.... and yummy strawberry flavored Red Rock Candy Crystals. Unit Price = $5.90/lb. Bag contains 5 pounds of Red Rock Candy Crystals. Made in the USA. Shipping Weight ~ 6 lbs. Kosher Certified.



Crime Scene Candy Tubes: 3-Piece Pack

…these candy bodily fluids are everything you need to solve mysterious crimes and nab the candy crooks in your life. The crime scene candy assortment includes three biological liquid candies: Blood, Urine, and Saliva with corresponding flavors of Cherry, Lemonade, and Apple. The Crime Scene Candy



AirHeads Bites Candy - Fruit: 9-Ounce Bag

…the go. We know, it will be hard not to eat them all in one sitting because they’re really delicious. Assorted Colors/Flavors: Green - Watermelon Blue - Raspberry Red - Cherry Orange - Orange White - Mystery Resealable bag contains 9 ounces of Fruit AirHeads Bites Candy. Shipping Weight ~ 3/4 lb.



Halloween Mega Candy Buttons Sheets: 2-Piece Pack

…of a large wart picked off the nose of a wicked witch, these jumbo candy buttons feature an fun assortment of spooky colors and flavors. Perfect for Halloween parties and events! Color - Flavor: Orange - Candy Corn White - Mystery Flavor Purple - Ghoulish Grape Green - Green Apple Button Diameter:…



Rock Candy Crystal Sticks - Light Pink: 120-Piece Case

When candy imitates life, mysterious events occur resulting in scrumptious delicacies. Let’s examine these Bubblegum Rock Crystal Sticks which have followed the same paradigm of the beautiful stone structures we find rooted in nature. Sugar molecule after sugar molecule arranges itself in random,…



AirHeads Taffy Candy Bars: 90-Piece Box

What do you get when you have 90 soft and stretchy AirHeads candy bars in 6 mouthwatering fruit flavors packed into 1 party-friendly AirHeads display box? A whole lotta crazy for you and your party guests. Now all you have to do is think of a reason to bust them out. That's the easy part. Includes…



Designer Halloween Candy Buffet Kit: 25 to 50 Guests

…done! Halloween is full of mystery, from the things that go bump in the night to the things that cover your dessert table at the annual Halloween party. Fortunately, you’ve decided to lay one of those mysteries to rest (in peace) with our Designer Halloween Candy Buffet Kit. It comes with everything…



Angry Birds PEZ Candy Dispensers: 4-Piece Collector's Tin

…so sweet come from a face that’s so surly?" Well, that we couldn’t tell you. It’s just the magic of PEZ. But you can continue to ponder in awe at the mystery as you chew on these sweet pellets. Collector's tin includes 4 Angry Birds PEZ dispensers plus 6 candy cartridges. Shipping Weight ~ 1 lb.

$20.00 $15.00


Starburst and Skittles Valentine Candy Packs: 40-Piece Bag

Pop quiz: What’s sweeter than a Valentine card on Valentine’s Day? Why, Valentine candy of course! These fun size packs of original Starburst and Skittles candies each feature festive Valentine greetings and a designated area to the include the names of gifters and recipients. Fun and fruity sweets…



Glass Zipper Bag 22-Ounce Candy Jar

…in air, this unique glass candy jar is sure to surprise and delight any gift recipient. Or simply impress visitors to your home or office with a mysterious display of sweets or snacks that will have them curious, intrigued, and amazed at the wonder of this crazy candy container! Jar Specifications-…



Ninja Hard Candy Lollipops: 12-Piece Pack

Hiiiiiiiiiii-Yah! Add some stealthy sweetness to your next candy display with these fun lollipops designed in the likeness of the ancient nun-chuck wielding warriors. Better eat them quick before they disappear in a mysterious cloud of smoke! Assortment includes 2 ninja designs in black and red.…



SweeTarts Mini Chewy Candy 3.75-Ounce Packs: 12-Piece Box

…impossible to use in any such game, because the pieces seem to mysteriously vanish any time we turn our backs. Even more curiously, we often find our opponents chewing merrily while we search for the lost spheres! Their disappearance is a mystery we’ll never solve. But even though we don’t recommend…



Rock Candy Crystals - Yellow: 5LB Box

Rare yellow diamonds mined from deep candy caves! Very mysterious...yummy lemon-flavored Yellow Rock Candy Crystals. Unit Price = $5.90/lb. Bag contains 5 pounds of Yellow Rock Candy Crystals. Made in the USA. Shipping Weight ~ 6 lbs. Kosher Certified.



Rainbow Vortex Wheels Hard Candy: 5LB Bag

…flavor creates a vortex rainbow, whirling around itself before mysteriously settling into small hard candy discs. Appearing calm in its stiff candy form, you pop one into your mouth and suddenly something magical occurs: the succulent candy creates an ocean of flavor in your mouth. You marvel at the…


Chupa Chups Lolllipops
Haribo Gummy
Hershey Kisses
Jolly Rancher Candy
PEZ Candy
Sour Patch Candy
Starburst Candy
Swedish Fish Candy
Tootsie Roll Industries
Twizzlers Candy